Grandparents are a vital part of family life – they offer love and support to children and parents, as well as an experienced (and sometimes, different) perspective which can be helpful for adult children just starting out in parenthood.
The older generation is also single-handedly taking care of much of the UK’s childcare – often for free. Surveys have found more than half (57%) of parents with kids under 13 rely on childcare support from at least one grandparent.
They are invaluable, there’s no denying it. But sometimes they can also step on their adult children’s toes by overruling their parenting decisions – and this is when things can really blow up.
Therapist Tina Chummun told HuffPost UK that from her experience in the therapy room, “overstepping occurs in pretty much every aspect of a child’s upbringing” – from daily routine and discipline to food choices, recreational activities, toys, schooling, and even friendships.
“When grandparents override parental authority, it can lead to frustration and resentment for parents, making them feel undermined in their role,” she said.
“Grandparents may believe they are showing love by giving children their favourite foods at all times, but quite forget that parents might have set mealtimes, in order to acclimatise the children into their family set up,” said the therapist.
“Parents might feel disempowered and resentful that their wishes are not recognised. Both parties might see themselves as ‘experts’ on the child.”
Another way grandparents commonly overstep is by ‘showing’ new parents how parenting should be done, or giving advice. This can “unwittingly questioning a couples’ competence”, which might not go down so well.
There might be a few factors at play here. Chummun, who is a member of Counselling Directory, suggested grandparents might struggle with boundaries due to their own emotional needs.
Many grandparents may not realise that the young parents themselves are learning how to be a family – and that they are no longer children, Bhattacharya suggested.
“There can be two attitudes here: the first, is something along the lines of, ‘I know better because I’ve done it before, so let me show you’,” she explained.
The second is more subtle, she noted, and is “a sense of competition between the parents and grandparents, which emerges in grandparents overruling the parents’ boundaries with their children”.
If you’re reading this article, you might relate to some of the themes the therapists have flagged in terms of how grandparents might overstep.
So, the big question now is: what can you do about it?
It’s likely you don’t want to fall out with your parents over this, but equally you don’t want to allow them to keep overruling your decisions where your children are concerned.
Here’s what therapists suggest...
First things first, you need to speak to your partner and set some clear boundaries on what you do and do not want for your family.
“Being split on how you want to raise your family can be confusing for others, since they might receive mixed messages on what boundaries are held and what happens if they are transgressed,” said Bhattacharya.
Regular, open communication is key here – and navigating these conversations requires a “balance of sensitivity, support, clarity and assertiveness”, said Chummun.
You should clearly outline what you need from your parents in their role as grandparents and where the boundaries lie.
Bhattacharya recommended sticking to: what happened (how did they overstep?), why it’s a problem and what would be helpful in future.
She also suggested it’s important to present a united front while negotiating boundaries with the grandparents. However, it’s better for the adult child to discuss directly with their parent, with their partner present.
Both therapists stress the importance of letting your parents know how much they are appreciated and valued.
“It’s important to affirm their place in the family while also making it clear that certain decisions ultimately rest with the parents,” said Chummun.
“Framing these conversations in a way that acknowledges the grandparent’s value, rather than making them feel dismissed, can help prevent defensiveness and resistance.”
Some people will take the feedback onboard immediately, but others may not.
“You might have to have the conversation a few times before a new behaviour is accepted and put in place. That is understandable, as you are asking someone to ‘learn’ something new,” said Bhattacharya.
Just like any relationship, it might take some work to get to where you want to be.
“Having a healthy relationship with one’s parents, grandparents, children, and grandchildren takes work. It requires mutual respect and understanding of the other’s perspective,” said the therapist.
“It requires an adult couple to be united in what they want for their relationship and their family. It asks for grandparents to recognise that their children are now independent adults, but might still need their parents, albeit differently from when they were children.
“When done well, an intergenerational family can be beneficial to everyone, especially the young children, who grow up with essential life skills, learning to navigate multiple relationships.”